One-on-One Walks vs Group Walks

One-on-One vs Group Dog Walks: Discover the benefits and differences to choose the best walk style for your furry friend’s health and happiness.

Ally Fodero

May 26, 2025 • 8 min read

Dog walker holding multiple leashes walking six dogs of various breeds on a city sidewalk on a cloudy day.

Choosing the right type of dog walk for your furry friend can feel like a puzzle. On the one hand, one-on-one dog walks offer a personalised experience that caters to your dog’s individual needs, providing undivided attention and care. This option is perfect for dogs who thrive with individual attention, have specific training needs, or simply prefer the peace of a solo adventure.

On the other hand, group dog walks bring the joy and excitement of social interaction, allowing dogs to play and learn from each other under the watchful eye of a professional walker. This can be a great way for your dog to expend extra energy and improve their social skills. Whether you lean towards the personalised care of one-on-one walks or the dynamic energy of group outings, this article dives into the benefits of both options to help you make the best decision for your canine companion.

Let’s explore what makes each option unique and how to choose the one that best suits your dog’s temperament, health, and happiness.

Benefits of One-on-One Dog Walks

One-on-one dog walks offer a plethora of benefits for both the dog and its owner, standing out as a personalised approach to pet care that fosters a deeper bond, ensures safety, and caters to the individual needs of the dog. 

One-on-one dog walks stand as a testament to personalised care, offering a multitude of benefits that contribute to a happier, healthier, and more well-behaved pet. This approach not only meets the physical and emotional needs of the dog but also provides peace of mind for the owner, knowing their beloved pet is receiving the best possible care.

Individual Attention and Care

One-on-one dog walks prioritise individual attention and care, ensuring that each dog receives the undivided attention of the walker. This personalised approach allows the walker to fully understand and cater to the unique personality, needs, and preferences of the dog. By focusing solely on one dog at a time, the walker can create a deep emotional bond and provide a nurturing environment that significantly enhances the dog’s well-being and happiness.

Customised Pace and Route for the Dog’s Needs

The beauty of one-on-one walks lies in the ability to customise the pace and route according to the dog’s specific needs and energy levels. Whether it’s a leisurely stroll for an older dog or a vigorous hike for a high-energy puppy, the walk can be tailored to ensure the dog receives the optimal amount of exercise without overexertion. This customisation extends to choosing quieter routes for anxious dogs or more stimulating paths for curious explorers, making every walk a perfectly suited adventure for the dog.

Ideal for Dogs with Special Needs or Behaviours

One-on-one walks offer personalised care for anxious dogs, providing a calm and controlled environment tailored to their needs. For dogs that are reactive, shy, or recovering from an injury, the personalised care and controlled environment of individual walks provide a safe and supportive setting for exercise and socialisation. The walker can focus on reinforcing positive behaviours, managing any challenges that arise, and ensuring the dog’s safety and comfort at all times.

This targeted approach is invaluable for helping dogs with special requirements to thrive and enjoy their walks to the fullest.

Benefits of Group Dog Walks

Group dog walks offer a unique set of advantages, chief among them being the opportunity for socialisation with other dogs. This interaction is crucial for developing good social skills as dogs learn to communicate and play with each other in a safe and controlled environment. 

For pet owners looking for a regular walking schedule, group walks tend to be more cost-effective, providing a budget-friendly solution without compromising on the quality of exercise and interaction their dogs receive.

Socialisation with Other Dogs

Group dog walks excel in providing socialisation opportunities with other dogs, which is essential for a dog’s social development. This interaction helps dogs learn appropriate behaviours and communication cues from each other, fostering a well-rounded and sociable pet.

Higher Energy Expenditure Through Play

One of the standout benefits of group walks is the higher energy expenditure dogs experience through play and interaction with their peers. This active engagement not only helps in maintaining a healthy weight but also in reducing common behavioural issues linked to excess energy.

More Cost-Effective for Regular Walks

For owners seeking a regular exercise routine for their dogs, group walks offer a more cost-effective solution. Sharing the walker’s time with other dogs lowers the cost per walk, making it an economically attractive option for consistent pet care.

Choosing Between One-on-One and Group Walks

Deciding between one-on-one and group dog walks involves considering several factors related to the dog’s temperament, behaviour, and social skills, as well as the owner’s goals and availability

Owners must reflect on their personal goals for their dog’s walks and their own schedules to choose the option that best aligns with their needs and their dog’s well-being.

Dog’s Temperament and Behaviour

Evaluating a dog’s temperament and behaviour is crucial in choosing the right type of walk. Dogs displaying aggression or excessive shyness may thrive in the controlled environment of one-on-one walks.

Aggressive or Overly Shy Dogs

Aggressive or overly shy dogs require specialised attention that can be better provided in a one-on-one setting, ensuring safety and a positive walking experience.

Dogs with High Energy Levels

Dogs with high energy levels often benefit from the dynamic and stimulating environment of group walks, where they can play and interact with other dogs.

Dog’s Social Skills and Compatibility

Considering a dog’s social skills and compatibility with other dogs is essential for group walks to ensure harmonious interactions and play.

Socially Adept Dogs

Socially adept dogs usually enjoy and excel in group walk settings, where they can socialise and engage with peers.

Dogs Needing Socialisation Practice

For dogs needing socialisation practice, group walks can provide a structured and safe environment to learn and improve their social skills.

Health and Age Considerations

Health and age considerations play a significant role in deciding the type of walk that is best for a dog, with special attention needed for senior dogs and puppies.

Senior Dogs with Limited Mobility

Senior dogs with limited mobility may require the gentler and more tailored approach of one-on-one walks to accommodate their physical needs.

Puppies with Vaccination Requirements

Puppies with vaccination requirements need to be kept safe while still being socialised, making one-on-one walks a preferable option until they can safely interact with other dogs.

Owner’s Goals and Availability

Owner’s goals and availability are important factors in choosing between walk types, whether the priority is specific training goals or fitting walks into a busy schedule.

Specific Training Goals

For owners with specific training goals, one-on-one walks provide the opportunity to focus on personalised training and behaviour correction.

Owners with Busy Schedules

Owners with busy schedules may find group walks a more convenient and time-efficient option for ensuring their dogs get necessary exercise and socialisation.

Potential Drawbacks of Each Option

While both one-on-one and group dog walks offer significant benefits, they come with potential drawbacks that owners should consider. Owners must weigh these considerations carefully to choose the best walking option that aligns with their dog’s needs and their personal circumstances.

One-on-One Walks Might Be More Expensive

One-on-one walks tend to be more expensive due to the personalised attention and tailored experience they offer. It’s important to consider the cost of individual dog walks when budgeting for your pet’s care.

Group Walks May Not Suit All Dogs

Group walks might not be the ideal choice for all dogs, particularly for those with aggressive tendencies or high anxiety levels. The social setting of group walks can overwhelm some dogs, potentially leading to stress or negative interactions.

Final Considerations Before Making a Decision

Before finalising the decision between one-on-one and group dog walks, it’s essential to consider trial sessions for both types of walks to observe firsthand how your dog adapts and responds. 

These considerations will help align your choice with your dog’s needs and your expectations, ensuring a positive outcome for both you and your pet.

Trial Sessions for Both Types of Walks

Trial sessions for both one-on-one and group walks are essential. They provide a practical way to assess how your dog reacts to each setting, helping you make an informed decision based on their comfort and happiness.

Professional Walker’s Experience and Approach

The experience and approach of the professional walker are critical factors. A walker skilled in handling various dog temperaments and behaviours can significantly enhance the walking experience, ensuring it’s beneficial and enjoyable for your dog.

Safety Measures for Group Walks

Safety measures in place for group walks are vital to consider. Proper protocols, such as matching dogs by size and temperament and ensuring all dogs are up-to-date on vaccinations, are essential for preventing incidents and ensuring the well-being of all participants.

Finding the Right Fit for Your Furry Friend

Understanding the nuances between one-on-one and group dog walks helps you choose what truly suits your dog’s personality, health, and daily needs. Whether your pup craves the calm of a private stroll or the lively energy of a pack, the right choice brings out their happiest self.

At Soulmutts, we get that every dog is unique. With a legacy of personalised care and professional dog walking service in Toronto, we create experiences tailored to your dog’s needs—whether it’s solo adventures or group pack fun.

Curious about which walk is best for your dog? Let’s chat and set up a trial with Soulmutts Toronto today because your dog deserves the best walk of its life.

Ally Fodero

Over a decade ago, Alison (Ally) Fodero – who was in the middle of completing her Masters degree at the time – returned home from a scuba diving trip to Honduras with an adopted stray dog that had followed her around during her time there. When she returned to the spot a year later, another stray dog became attached to her – one who turned out to be the sister of her dog at home, as a local informed her. Nonetheless, the adoption of the second dog was inevitable and a beautiful reunion ensued in the parking lot at Pearson International Airport. It was then that “Soulmutts” became an idea, one that would begin with one truck, one dog walker, and five or six dogs in a park.

Discover the Care, Play, and Companionship Your Dog Will Love
Join Our Dog Pack Today!